When a manufacturer claims a smaller deviation than the standard, which value applies?

Applies to: ISO 6789-1:2017 · Updated 2026-11-17

Technical review: Alston Hsiao (Chieh-Jen Hsiao), CTO, STAND

Key answer

When a manufacturer claims a maximum permissible relative deviation smaller than the value tabulated in the standard, every result must meet the claimed value. A result that exceeds the claim cannot be judged as conforming by falling back on the wider tabulated tolerance. The capability of the measurement device must also be checked against this smaller claimed value.

First pin down the claim that applies

Subclause 5.1.5 of ISO 6789-1:2017 not only specifies the limits for each class but also covers the case where a manufacturer claims a smaller deviation. For purchasing or quality control, the first step is to confirm whether the claim applies to this tool, this torque range, and these operating directions, and then match it to the test records.

For example, if the information says only “as low as ±2 %” without stating the applicable models or conditions, that is not yet enough to apply it directly to every tool. First obtain a clear specification; once it is confirmed as the claim applicable to this tool, each result is judged against that value.

Within the tabulated value, yet still outside the claim

The following is teaching data: suppose a Type II Class A wrench has a specified range of 20–100 N·m, a tabulated tolerance of ±4 % in the applicable direction, and a manufacturer’s claim of ±2 % over the whole specified range. At a target value of 60 N·m, the measurement device gives an observed value of 61.8 N·m.

Calculated in accordance with Part 1:

a_d = (61.8 − 60) ÷ 60 × 100 = +3.0 %

Although this result is within ±4 %, it exceeds the manufacturer’s claimed upper limit of +2 %. It therefore cannot be recorded as conforming to that claim. Nor can this out-of-limit result be averaged away using other readings that were closer to the target.

A claimed value is a limit that results must meet, not merely comparative wording in a product description. The declaration of conformance must state the maximum permissible relative deviation adopted under subclause 5.1.5, so the recipient knows the criterion used for the decision.

The device must also support the smaller limit

Subclause 6.1 of Part 1 requires that, at each target value, the maximum measurement error of the measurement device must not exceed one quarter of the tool’s claimed maximum permissible relative deviation.

Continuing with the teaching data above, the upper limit for the device’s relative error magnitude is 2 % ÷ 4 = 0.5 %. Checking the device against the tabulated 4 % ÷ 4 = 1 % would use the wrong basis. What is compared here is the device’s maximum measurement error; the uncertainty of the device or the tool is not substituted in the same place.

When receiving tools, you can therefore check the tool’s claimed value, the relative deviation of each result, and the evidence of the device’s capability at each target value together. This example only demonstrates how to read one out-of-limit result; it does not represent the performance of any actual product or equipment.